1. Purpose of this two-part series
Most NGOs run several projects at once, each funded by a different donor, while sharing one office, one finance team and one leadership team. The costs of these shared resources, called common costs (should not be misunderstood as indirect costs or overheads in absence of standardisation in nomenclature), cannot be charged entirely to any single project. They must be shared among projects on a fair, documented basis.
This series explains what common costs are, why the way they are allocated matters under Indian law and donor agreements, the three pieces of Common Costs framework, and a complete worked example (organisation names and figures are fictitious used only for illustration).
Please note that this two-part series does not answer all questions but provides a good beginning to introduction of evidence based common costs in NPOs.
2. What are common costs and why it matters to NPOs?
A common cost is an expense that benefits more than one project or activity and therefore cannot be traced/attributed to a particular project without some form of apportionment. A direct cost, by contrast, is incurred specifically for one project (for example, teaching material for the Education project).
Table 1: Typical common costs in an NPO
| Common cost |
|---|
| Office rent, maintenance, security |
| Electricity, water, internet, telephone |
| Senior/General management salary |
| Finance, HR and administration staff |
| Statutory audit and legal fees |
| Vehicles, fuel and drivers |
| IT systems, software licences, accounting software |
| Insurance, bank charges, office supplies |
| Board / governance meeting costs, annual report |
Common cost allocation is not just a bookkeeping exercise, Indian regulations and funder conditions place limits on or require evidence for the shared/common costs/overheads charged to a grant.
For instance, under FCRA, Admin expenditure cannot be more than 20% of FC receipts in a financial year. You may note that Admin expenditure are generally Common/shared costs and therefore care should be taken that the Admin expenditure ceiling is not breached. Similarly, CSR funders incorporate common/shared costs that would be admissible as per CSR Policy.
3. The Three pieces of Common/shared Costs Framework
The three key pieces of a framework of common/shared costs are as follows:
-
Common Cost Pool/Category: Support/Admin staff, Facilities, Leadership & Governance etc as shown in Table 1 above. Each of the costs when bucketed in a category since they are similar in nature is collectively called common cost pool.
-
Allocation Method/Driver/Base: These may include
-
Time allocated/spent: Program, HR, Finance & Compliance staff, (backbone).
-
Headcount: Resource Mobilization, IT, Capacity Building, General Comms, Office supplies.
-
Square footage: rent, utilities, maintenance.
-
Usage: vehicle.
-
Direct Allocation Method (percentage of direct costs): simple and easy to implement.
While the individual common cost may have one of the allocation base as above, for arriving at the common cost rate for the organisation for budgeting in project grant proposals, the sum total of all common costs to all total direct costs is used for demonstrating and justifying the rate to the donors.
- Full Cost Recovery: such that Income = Expenditure.
This is critical for ensuring that NPO does not have to dip into its own resources which are scarce for meeting common/shared costs which justifiably should be paid by grant project funds.
4. Principles of fair allocation method/base
-
Causality: choose a basis that reflects what actually drives the cost. Rent follows space, vehicle cost follows kilometres.
-
Reasonableness: the result must be justifiable to a donor, auditor or tax officer.
-
Consistency: apply the same method every year and disclose any change with reasons.
-
Documentation: keep timesheets, logbooks, floor plans and the board-approved cost allocation policy.
-
No double charging: a cost charged directly to a project must not also be in the common pool.
-
Respect restrictions: never allocate more to a restricted grant than its agreement or the law allows.
5. Common Cost allocation methods/bases
| Basis | Formula | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Direct cost | Project direct cost ÷ total direct cost | Finance, audit, governance |
| Headcount / FTE | Project FTE ÷ total FTE | Utilities, supplies, IT |
| Floor area | Area used ÷ total area | Rent, maintenance |
| Time spent | Hours on project ÷ total hours | Management and shared staff |
| Usage / km | Usage by project ÷ total usage | Vehicles, photocopying |
| Equal share | Cost ÷ number of projects | Rarely; small fixed costs |
We hope this has been informative. Please raise your queries and clarifications here. We will be here tomorrow with Part 2 of the series.